The Fish Guru

Nerite vs Mystery Snails: A Guide to Choosing the Right Aquarium Inhabitant

Aquariums are a popular addition to any household, but choosing the right inhabitants can be a daunting task. Snails are often a great way to add color and life to your aquarium, and two of the most popular species are Nerite and Mystery snails.

These species may look similar, but they have distinct differences in their physical appearance, behavior, and care requirements. This article will compare and contrast the Nerite and Mystery snails, providing the information necessary to make an informed choice for your aquarium.

Taxonomy

The Nerite snail belongs to the Neritidae family, while the Mystery snail, also known as the Apple snail, belongs to the Ampullariidae family. The Nerita snail family has over 200 species found mainly in Africa and South America.

On the other hand, the Ampullariidae family is found mainly in South America and Africa. Both species are known for their hardy nature and adaptability.

Origin & Habitat

Nerite snails can be found in both freshwater and brackish water environments. They are found in Africa and South America, and some species can be found in the Indo-Pacific region.

Nerite snails are known to be great algae eaters, helping to keep tanks clean. Mystery snails are from South America and are commonly found in freshwater environments such as rivers, streams, and lakes.

They are also adaptable to a brackish water environment. They are known to be great scavengers, eating leftover fish food and detritus.

Physical Appearance

Both the Nerite and Mystery snails come in a range of colors and patterns, making them popular additions to any aquarium. Nerite snails shells are generally thick and hard, making them less susceptible to cracks and breaks.

The shell color can range from black, brown, green, and yellow, and some species have intricate and unique patterns on their shell. Mystery snails also come in a range of colors, including gold, ivory, blue, and brown.

They have a thicker operculum and a round body with a thin foot. Mystery snails have a thinner shell than Nerite snails, making them more susceptible to breaks and cracks.

Behavior & Compatibility

Both snail species are peaceful and solitary animals that are easy to care for. They are great tank mates for other peaceful fish species.

Nerite snails prefer to keep to themselves, while Mystery snails can enjoy moving around with other snail species. The only fish species not compatible with these two snail species are large, aggressive fish species that would eat or harm the snails.

Care & Tank Requirements

Both snail species require similar care and tank requirements. The water temperature should be between 72 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit, with a pH range of 7.0 to 8.0. A minimum tank size of 5 gallons is recommended for both species, and live plants are a great addition to their environment.

Regular water changes should be done weekly or biweekly to keep the water clean and healthy for the snails. Diet & Feedings

Both the Nerite and Mystery snails are herbivores and detritivores, meaning they eat algae and leftover food.

Nerite snails prefer to feed during daylight hours, while Mystery snails are nocturnal feeders. Both species should be fed algae wafers and blanched vegetables such as zucchini and spinach.

Breeding

Nerite snails are notoriously difficult to breed in captivity, with successful breeding resulting in small numbers of eggs. Mystery snails are known for their high reproduction rates, with one egg clutch containing up to 300 eggs.

Unfertilized eggs can also be laid, resulting in babies hatching with only one parent. This makes Mystery snails popular among breeders looking to produce snails with unique colors and patterns.

Health Issues & Diseases

Both snail species are hardy and rarely experience health issues. However, there are a few conditions that may occur in both species.

A swollen foot is a common issue in both species, and a snail’s operculum may close due to stress or injury. Mantle collapse can occur in Mystery snails, and floating is a common issue for both species.

It is important to monitor your snails’ health regularly to identify any potential issues.

Cost of Keeping as a Pet

The cost of keeping Nerite and Mystery snails as pets is relatively low. The initial cost of the snails is affordable, and their food sources are also inexpensive.

The cost of cleaning supplies and equipment, as well as the frequency of cleaning, can vary depending on the size of the aquarium and number of inhabitants.

Conclusion

Nerite and Mystery snails are great additions to any aquarium, adding color and life to the environment. Both species have unique physical characteristics, behaviors, and care requirements.

When deciding on which snail species to add to your aquarium, it is important to consider their suitability for your tank size, compatibility with other inhabitants, and their care and feeding requirements. With proper care, both species can live long and healthy lives in your aquarium.

Mystery Snails

Key Differences from Nerite Snails

One of the key differences between Mystery Snails and Nerite Snails is in their breeding. Mystery Snails are much easier to breed in captivity, making them a popular choice for those who are looking to breed snails in their aquarium.

Another significant difference is their lifespan. Mystery Snails have a shorter lifespan compared to Nerite Snails.

While Nerite Snails can live up to five years, Mystery Snails tend to live only for two to three years.

Physical Appearance

Mystery Snails have a thick, round shell that is usually a solid color, such as ivory, gold, blue, or brown. Their shells can grow up to three inches in diameter, making them slightly larger than Nerite Snails.

Behavior and Compatibility

Mystery Snails are known for their peaceful nature, and they are easy to care for. They are excellent tank mates for other peaceful fish species, although they are susceptible to being eaten by larger, aggressive fish.

Therefore, it is crucial to be mindful when selecting tankmates if you want to keep Mystery Snails as pets.

Care and Tank Requirements

Mystery Snails require similar care to Nerite Snails, with a water temperature between 72 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit, pH range between 7.0 to 8.0, and a minimum tank size of 5 gallons. Unlike Nerite Snails, Mystery Snails require calcium-rich diets.

Live plants are also an excellent addition to their environment.

Diet and Feedings

Mystery Snails are herbivores and detritivores, meaning they eat algae and leftover food. The primary food source for Mystery Snails is algae and blanched vegetables such as zucchini and spinach.

Breeding

Mystery Snails are known for their ability to reproduce easily in captivity. Unlike Nerite Snails, whose eggs are not visible to the naked eye, Mystery Snails lay large clutches of eggs on surfaces above the waterline.

These eggs are visible and easily identifiable, making it easy to spot when they’re breeding. Nerite Snails vs.

Mystery Snails

When comparing Nerite and Mystery Snails, personal preference plays a significant role in determining which species is the best fit. Nerite Snails are hardy, and their lifespan can be longer than that of Mystery Snails.

They are also excellent algae eaters, competing with Mystery Snails for the same food source. On the other hand, Mystery Snails are easier to breed, with visible and identifiable egg clutches.

They have a peaceful nature, making them great tank mates for other peaceful fish species. It is essential to note that both species make great additions to any aquarium, and the joy and companionship they provide outweigh any drawbacks.

FAQs

1. Are Mystery Snails beginner-friendly?

Yes, Mystery Snails are beginner-friendly. They are hardy, easy to care for, and compatible with most peaceful fish species.

However, it is important to be mindful of potential tankmates that could harm them. 2.

Can Nerite and Mystery Snails live together? It is not recommended to keep Nerite and Mystery Snails together in the same tank.

They both compete for the same food sources, and their care requirements differ slightly, making it easier to manage them separately. 3.

Are Nerite and Mystery Snails worth it? Yes, both Nerite and Mystery Snails are worth it.

They are low-maintenance, colourful, and excellent at keeping the aquarium clean. They are also relatively inexpensive to keep.

4. Do Nerite and Mystery Snails eat algae?

Yes, both Nerite and Mystery Snails eat algae. They are excellent algae eaters and help keep the tank clean.

5. Are Nerite and Mystery Snails good cleaners?

Yes, both species are good cleaners. They clean up leftover fish food, detritus, and algae, helping to keep the tank clean and healthy.

In conclusion, Nerite Snails and Mystery Snails are fascinating and colorful additions to any aquarium. Both species have unique physical characteristics, behaviors, and care requirements.

When deciding between the two, consider factors such as suitability for your tank size, compatibility with other inhabitants, and their care and feeding requirements. Ultimately, personal preference plays a significant role in determining which species is the best fit.

The joy and companionship that snails provide for aquarists outweigh any drawbacks. They are low-maintenance, budget-friendly, and easy to care for, making them an excellent choice for novice and experienced aquarists alike.

Popular Posts